Keys to the Match | FC Cincinnati take on Orland City SC in Wild Card Round of MLS Cup Playoffs

cropped_20261031 FCCvsPHI DB1 4715-2

It’s all on the line now as FC Cincinnati kick off the 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs in a one-game, winner-take-all Wild Card Round matchup against Orlando City SC on Thursday night, traveling down to Inter & Co. Stadium to secure their place in the next round of the postseason.

The matchup with Orlando kicks off at 7:30 p.m. on Thursday, with a winner decided no matter what; if a draw needs to be broken, the game goes directly to a penalty shootout at the end of full time. Before we get there, let’s look at a few key factors FC Cincinnati will need to guide them to victory in this playoff duel!

No Second Chances

This one is for all the marbles, so to speak. While a win in this Wild Card round sets you up for a Best-of-3 series with Nashville SC, this one-game, winner-take-all matchup with Orlando means your season is on the line. So playing as such is a must, and meeting the moment will be paramount for success on Thursday night. 

FC Cincinnati have not been stellar on the road this season, but down the stretch of the regular season they have raised their performance level and shown they can play very well in must-win games. With wins over Atlanta and D.C. United and a hard-fought draw against a top Inter Miami side, all on the road in the final month of the 2026 season, there is more proof now that FCC can meet the moment, but the pressure will still be there. 

“There's an intensity about everything,” FC Cincinnati defender Nick Hagglund said of the playoffs on Monday. “Guys are a bit nervous, you make one mistake and it's in the back of the net, and that could be your season. I think people are a little bit more cautious. I feel like in the playoffs, every time the ball moves, something could happen, and I feel like that feeling that creates a pressure and intensity and excitement, all these little different emotions that you're going through in one moment. Every time the ball moves, something different's happening over the course of 90 minutes. You hope to be on the better side of that, and I think the margins on any playoff game are small. Even the best teams that have played in MLS, you're in the playoffs, and it comes down to one moment, one play that changes the game for you, and so you have that feeling the entire game.”

Hagglund said his approach to these moments is to fall back on his experience and try to make the games as normal as possible. He said it’s better to play clear-headed than to play with the anxiety that comes with the intensity; he’s played 1000’s of soccer games, he explains and trying to be the “best version of Nick” makes the most sense to him. 

Bring Intensity

That all being said, there is a pressure and an intensity that these kinds of games bring that is inescapable. The pressure of a playoff defeat and elimination on the road is not something FC Cincinnati, as a club, is historically familiar with; they only went on the road like this in the 2022 season, when the team's context was far different.

That being said, FCC have shown a “never say die” attitude all season. They have fought back and fought through to the final whistle time and time again to earn points, and on Thursday will need to continue that mentality no matter the score.

“Yeah, our backs are against the wall. But the thing about this group is, I feel like we've had a lot of opportunities where we've been backed against the wall – 90’ and we need a goal, or we need to tie the game, or whatever – and I think we've responded well,” Hagglund continued. “I think in the last four games…our backs were kind of against the wall there, and we had to get points and had to get results, and I think we did. 

“So again, it's the playoffs. You're going away to Orlando, it's going to be us-versus-them in that stadium, and we have to be up for it.”

Another element of this game is that Orlando, of all teams, plays with a particular intensity that sets them apart. So on top of the intensity that comes with a playoff game, FC Cincinnati need to ready themselves for an Orlando squad that likes to up the pace and play with physicality. 

“The intensity, you can feel the atmosphere and the urgency from everyone to get the win,” defender Kyle Smith said of the kind of game Orlando likes to play. Smith, while a Cincinnati native, played the previous seven seasons with OCSC before joining FCC this year. “We have to match their work ethic and the amount of running. Because they run a lot. They get behind the ball and everyone defends.”

Control the Space

Building off that point from Smith, on top of the intangible elements of the game, like intensity or mental preparation for a high-stakes game, there are further things to prepare for in terms of how Orlando plays and how to counter them.

Orlando is known for its willingness to run, apply pressure to opponents, and play physically to make opponents uncomfortable. That style, combined with their acclimation to the summer heat in Florida, has made them a very effective team at home and always a tough team to beat. That makes managing that press, controlling the space and pace of the game, and playing as a collective even more vital than ever for FC Cincinnati. 

“It's always been a staple. Their teams, and with what we've seen from you know their group with the new additions post-transfer window, they compete,” FC Cincinnati Head Coach Pat Noonan said. “It'll be a great atmosphere, and yeah, against any Orlando team, you have to be able to match that, and then all the other details of playing the game and trying to find advantages and things that you look at in preparation. All that is is the next piece of just matching energy and an ability to compete with a team like Orlando.”

“We need to continue the connectivity between our group, offensive and defensively,” Hagglund added. “ I think over the last month we've been really connected, forward and back, closing the spaces. I think if we can close the space and not allow Greizmann and Ojeda to come into the midfield –  if we can close that space between our midfielders and our defense – I think we'll be able to get more turnovers and ultimately limit their ability to make playmaking actions in the game.” 

The difference between this game and the one they played in Orlando earlier this year is that the weather looks far more amenable. In August, the heat played a significant role in the game, but Thursday is expected to be much cooler and, likely, a little wetter, which could be advantageous.

“I think the temperatures are going to be kinder, and I think the intensity will certainly increase,” Noonan added. “And I think with players, when they know that they have to win a game or they're done, the energy is not going to drop off. So I think that allows for a faster pace game than maybe when we played there, that's the biggest difference. Detail-wise, I think there are some things – it feels like forever ago that we played them, but I think that was mid-August at their place, so, it's not too long ago – so we will look at a couple of the details from that game to just help guide us.”

FC Cincinnati kicks off with Orlando at 7:30 p.m. on Saturday at Inter & Co. Stadium. For more information on attending the match, how to watch, or for further matchday information, click here.